Easy2Siksha.com
GNDU Question Paper-2023
Bachelor of Commerce
(B.Com) 3
rd
Semester
FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT
Time Allowed: Three Hours Max. Marks: 50
Note: Attempt Five questions in all, selecting at least One question from each section and the
Fifth question may be attempted from any of the Four sections. All questions carry equal marks
SECTION-A
1. Examine the various techniques employed to adjust the time value of money.
2. What is the relevance of cost of capital in capital budgeting and capital structure
planning decisions?
SECTION-B
3. What is Operating Leverage? How does it help in magnifying revenue of a concern?
4. Explain the term capital structure and mention the factors affecting capital structure.
SECTION-C
5. What factors would you take into consideration in estimating the Working Capital
needs of a concern?
6. Discuss the various recommendations of Tandon Committee on Working Capital.
Easy2Siksha.com
SECTION-D
7. What do you understand by Capital Budgeting process ? Enumerate briefly the major
steps involved in capital budgeting.
8. Discuss the Walter's and Gordon's model of Dividend Policy.
Easy2Siksha.com
GNDU Answer Paper-2023
Bachelor of Commerce
(B.Com) 3
rd
Semester
FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT
Time Allowed: Three Hours Max. Marks: 50
Note: Attempt Five questions in all, selecting at least One question from each section and the
Fifth question may be attempted from any of the Four sections. All questions carry equal marks
SECTION-A
1. Examine the various techniques employed to adjust the time value of money.
Ans: The Story of Money and Time
Imagine this: You and your best friend are sitting in a park on a sunny afternoon, eating ice
cream. Suddenly, your friend asks you a tricky question:
“If I give you ₹1,000 today or ₹1,000 after five years, which one would you choose?”
At first, the answer seems obvious—you’ll take it today! But then your friend smiles and
says, “Why though? Isn’t ₹1,000 the same whether it’s today or after five years?”
And that, my friend, is the doorway into the fascinating world of the Time Value of Money
(TVM)—the idea that the value of money changes depending on when you receive or spend
it. Just like ice cream melts over time, the power of money also changes. Money in your
hands today can grow, earn interest, or be invested, making it worth more tomorrow.
Waiting too long means losing that opportunity.
To make decisions about loans, savings, investments, or even business projects, we need
techniques to adjust for this time difference. These techniques help us compare money
received today with money to be received in the future, and vice versa. Now, let’s explore
them like a storyteller walking you through different tools in a treasure chest.
Easy2Siksha.com
1. Future Value (FV): The Power of Growth
Think of Future Value as planting a mango seed today and watching it turn into a tree
tomorrow. The seed is your money today, and the tree full of mangoes is your money in the
future.
Definition: Future Value tells us how much today’s money will grow into after a certain
period, if it earns interest or returns.
Formula:
Where:
• PV = Present Value (money today)
• r = rate of interest
• n = number of years
Example (Story mode):
Suppose you keep ₹1,000 in the bank at 10% interest. After 1 year, you’ll have ₹1,100. After
2 years, it will grow to ₹1,210. That’s the magic of compounding—money growing on
money.
So, when we want to know how today’s money will look in the future, we calculate its
Future Value.
2. Present Value (PV): The Reverse Journey
If Future Value is like planting a seed, Present Value is like taking a ripe mango and asking:
“If this mango grew from a seed years ago, how big was that seed?”
Definition: Present Value brings future money back to today’s value. It tells us what future
cash flows are worth today after considering interest or discounting.
Formula:
Easy2Siksha.com
Example:
If someone promises you ₹2,000 after 3 years and the interest rate is 10%, what is it worth
today?
So, ₹2,000 after 3 years is equal to about ₹1,503 today. This is why people prefer money
now instead of later.
3. Discounting: Time Travel to the Present
Imagine you own a magical time machine. You can travel into the future, grab your money,
and bring it back to today. That’s what discounting does—it discounts future cash flows to
the present.
Definition: Discounting is the technique of finding Present Value by reducing (or
“discounting”) the future value with the help of a discount rate.
Why important? Because businesses often compare future inflows with today’s costs.
Without discounting, they might overestimate the worth of future money.
4. Compounding: Money’s Magic Multiplier
If discounting is traveling back in time, compounding is traveling forward. It’s like watching a
snowball roll down a hill, getting bigger and bigger as it collects more snow.
Definition: Compounding is the process of earning “interest on interest.” It tells us how
money grows over time when it is reinvested.
There are two types:
• Simple Compounding: Interest is calculated only on the original sum.
• Compound Compounding: Interest is calculated on both the original sum and the
accumulated interest.
Example:
₹1,000 at 10% simple interest for 3 years = ₹1,300.
But with compound interest = ₹1,331.
That extra ₹31 comes from the “interest on interest.” That’s the real power of
compounding.
Easy2Siksha.com
5. Annuities: Regular Cash Flows Over Time
Think of annuities like your Netflix subscription—regular payments every month. Or like a
pension, where you receive money regularly after retirement.
There are two major types:
1. Ordinary Annuity: Payments are made at the end of each period (like loan EMIs).
2. Annuity Due: Payments are made at the beginning of each period (like rent).
Formulas help us:
• Calculate the Present Value of an annuity (how much those future payments are
worth today).
• Calculate the Future Value of an annuity (how much those payments will grow to in
the future).
This is extremely useful for retirement planning, loan repayment, and investment decisions.
6. Perpetuities: Money Forever
Imagine someone promises you ₹100 every year forever. Sounds like magic, right? That’s a
perpetuity—a type of annuity that never ends.
Formula:
Where C = cash inflow per year, r = discount rate.
It is rare in real life but useful for valuing things like government bonds or endowments.
7. Effective Interest Rate (EIR): The Real Cost of Money
Banks often advertise “10% interest,” but the real cost may be higher depending on how
frequently they compound. If interest is compounded monthly, the effective rate is more
than 10%.
Formula:
Easy2Siksha.com
Where m = number of compounding periods.
This technique helps investors and borrowers compare different financial products fairly.
8. Net Present Value (NPV): The Decision Maker
In business, NPV is like a judge who tells you whether an investment is good or bad.
Definition: NPV is the difference between the Present Value of future cash inflows and the
Present Value of cash outflows.
• If NPV > 0 → Investment is profitable.
• If NPV < 0 → Better to reject it.
This technique is widely used in capital budgeting.
9. Internal Rate of Return (IRR): The Break-Even Rate
IRR is like asking: “At what rate will my money break even?”
Definition: It is the rate at which NPV becomes zero. Businesses use IRR to evaluate
projects—the higher the IRR, the better the project.
Wrapping It Up (The Moral of the Story)
So, when your friend asked whether ₹1,000 today or ₹1,000 after five years is better, the
answer wasn’t just about money—it was about understanding the time value of money.
• Future Value shows how money grows.
• Present Value and Discounting bring future money back.
• Compounding makes money snowball.
• Annuities and Perpetuities explain regular cash flows.
• EIR, NPV, and IRR help us make smarter financial decisions.
In simple words: Money today is more powerful than the same amount tomorrow. That’s
why wise people invest, save, and calculate before deciding. The techniques of TVM are like
magical lenses—they allow us to see money not just as currency, but as a living, growing
resource.
Easy2Siksha.com
And so, the next time someone asks you that ice-cream question—₹1,000 today or later—
you’ll not only smile but also explain an entire world of financial wisdom behind your choice.
2. What is the relevance of cost of capital in capital budgeting and capital structure
planning decisions?
Ans: The Relevance of Cost of Capital in Capital Budgeting and Capital Structure Planning
Imagine you are the captain of a ship about to begin a long voyage. Before you sail, you
need to know two important things:
1. How much fuel your ship consumes to travel a certain distance.
2. Which route will be the most efficient and safe to reach your destination.
Now, think of “fuel” as the cost of capital, and the “route” as the investment or financing
decision you need to make. Just as fuel efficiency guides your journey, cost of capital guides
a business in its financial decision-making. Whether the business is evaluating a new project
(capital budgeting) or deciding how to finance itself (capital structure planning), the cost of
capital becomes the central reference point.
Warming up to the Idea of Cost of Capital
At its core, the cost of capital is the minimum return a company must earn to satisfy its
providers of funds — shareholders, debt holders, or preference shareholders. In simple
words, it’s like the “price” a business pays for using other people’s money.
• If the company borrows from a bank, the interest it pays is the cost.
• If the company raises money from shareholders, the expected dividend and increase
in share price is the cost.
• When both sources are mixed, the overall weighted average is called Weighted
Average Cost of Capital (WACC).
So, cost of capital is not just an abstract financial term. It is like a guiding compass that tells
a firm whether to say “yes” or “no” to a project and how to arrange its finances wisely.
Cost of Capital in Capital Budgeting Decisions
Now let’s shift to capital budgeting. Imagine you are running a school and planning to build
a new science lab. Before you spend crores on construction, equipment, and staff, you ask
yourself: “Will this lab generate enough value in the long run?” This is exactly the essence of
capital budgeting — deciding which long-term projects deserve investment.
Easy2Siksha.com
But here comes the twist: how do you judge if the project is good enough? The answer lies
in comparing the project’s return with the cost of capital.
1. As a Benchmark (Hurdle Rate):
Suppose your company’s cost of capital is 12%. That means investors expect at least
12% return for giving you their money. If your new project generates 15%, you go
ahead, because it clears the hurdle. If it generates only 10%, you drop it —
otherwise, you would actually be destroying value.
2. In Net Present Value (NPV) Calculations:
In capital budgeting, future cash flows are discounted back to the present using the
cost of capital. Think of it like checking today’s worth of tomorrow’s money. If the
present value of inflows exceeds the cost of capital, the project is profitable.
3. In Internal Rate of Return (IRR):
The IRR is compared directly with cost of capital. If IRR is higher, the project is
accepted. So again, cost of capital acts like a yardstick.
4. Risk Adjustment:
Different projects carry different risks. A risky project may require a higher return
compared to a safe one. Cost of capital helps adjust for this risk by raising or
lowering the discount rate.
So, in simple words, in capital budgeting decisions, the cost of capital works like the “exam
pass mark.” If the project’s return is higher than the pass mark, you move forward. If not,
you reject it.
Cost of Capital in Capital Structure Planning
Now let’s shift gears to capital structure — which simply means the way a firm finances
itself: by using equity, debt, or a mix of both. Imagine you are cooking a dish, and you have
to decide the right balance of salt (debt) and spices (equity). Too much of one can spoil the
taste.
Here’s where cost of capital enters as the balancing element.
1. Debt vs. Equity:
o Debt is cheaper than equity because interest payments are tax-deductible.
o However, too much debt increases risk, which raises the cost of both debt
and equity.
So, managers must find the “sweet spot” where the overall WACC is the lowest.
2. Optimal Capital Structure:
The goal of financial planning is to minimize the cost of capital and maximize the
value of the firm. Think of it like adjusting the sails of your ship so that the wind
pushes you forward with the least resistance.
Easy2Siksha.com
3. Investor Expectations:
Different investors expect different returns. Equity holders want higher returns
because they take more risk. Debt holders want security and interest payments. By
calculating cost of capital, managers can understand these expectations and
structure financing accordingly.
4. Long-Term Strategy:
Cost of capital isn’t just about current decisions. It affects a firm’s reputation in
financial markets. A company that maintains an optimal capital structure and
controls its cost of capital will find it easier to raise funds in the future.
The Bigger Picture: Why Cost of Capital Matters So Much
Let’s tie it all together. Cost of capital is important because:
• It acts as a measuring stick for judging new investments.
• It serves as a compass in choosing the right mix of financing.
• It links the expectations of investors with the company’s growth strategies.
• It ensures that every rupee invested brings in value greater than what it costs.
Without knowing the cost of capital, a company would be like a ship sailing without a
compass — it may keep moving but will not know whether it is heading in the right direction
or sinking investor wealth.
A Simple Story to Remember
Picture a farmer deciding whether to buy a new tractor. The tractor costs ₹10 lakhs, and the
farmer borrows money from the bank at an interest rate of 10%. This 10% is the cost of
capital. If the tractor helps him earn 15% extra income in the coming years, he goes ahead
and buys it. But if it only brings 7% return, it’s better to avoid the purchase.
Now, suppose the farmer has two financing options:
• Take a loan from the bank (cheap but risky if crops fail).
• Invite his friend as a partner (costlier since profit must be shared, but less risky).
He will compare both options and choose the mix that keeps his overall cost lowest while
keeping him safe from risk.
That’s exactly what companies do in capital budgeting and capital structure planning.
Conclusion
Easy2Siksha.com
The relevance of cost of capital is like the importance of oxygen to human life. Without it,
no investment or financing decision can survive. In capital budgeting, it tells whether a
project will create or destroy wealth. In capital structure planning, it guides how to arrange
the sources of funds in the cheapest and most efficient way.
In short, cost of capital is not just a financial figure — it is the heartbeat of corporate
decision-making. It ensures that companies sail in the right direction, invest wisely, and
grow in a way that satisfies investors.
SECTION-B
3. What is Operating Leverage? How does it help in magnifying revenue of a concern?
Ans: Scene 1 — The Roller Coaster Analogy
In our amusement park story:
• The track is the company’s fixed costs — it’s already built, whether one person rides
or a thousand.
• The cars are the products or services — they move along the track.
• The ticket sales are the revenue.
• The lever is operating leverage — it determines how much a change in ticket sales
affects the park’s profit.
If the track (fixed costs) is expensive to build but cheap to run each extra car (low variable
cost), then once you’ve covered the cost of the track, every extra ticket sold is almost pure
profit. That’s high operating leverage.
What is Operating Leverage?
Definition (humanised): Operating leverage is the degree to which a company uses its fixed
costs in its cost structure. It measures how sensitive a company’s operating profit (EBIT) is to
a change in sales.
• High operating leverage: A small change in sales → a big change in operating profit.
• Low operating leverage: A change in sales → a smaller, proportional change in
operating profit.
🏗 The Cost Structure Behind It
Every business has:
1. Fixed Costs — Costs that don’t change with production or sales volume in the short
term. Examples: Factory rent, salaried staff, insurance, depreciation.
Easy2Siksha.com
2. Variable Costs — Costs that change directly with production or sales volume.
Examples: Raw materials, packaging, sales commissions.
High fixed costs + low variable costs = High operating leverage.
The Formula (kept simple)
The Degree of Operating Leverage (DOL) at a given sales level is:
Or, from cost data:
Where:
• Contribution Margin = Sales − Variable Costs
• EBIT = Contribution Margin − Fixed Costs
A Simple Example
Imagine a company:
• Sales = ₹1,00,000
• Variable Costs = ₹40,000
• Fixed Costs = ₹50,000
Contribution Margin = ₹1,00,000 − ₹40,000 = ₹60,000 EBIT = ₹60,000 − ₹50,000 = ₹10,000
Now, sales increase by 10% → Sales = ₹1,10,000 Variable Costs = ₹44,000 (still 40% of sales)
Contribution Margin = ₹66,000 EBIT = ₹66,000 − ₹50,000 = ₹16,000
EBIT change = ₹10,000 → ₹16,000 = +60% Sales change = +10% So, DOL = 60% / 10% = 6.
This means: For every 1% change in sales, EBIT changes by 6%.
How It Magnifies Revenue Impact
Here’s the magic: Once fixed costs are covered, each extra rupee of sales mostly adds to
profit because variable costs are low. That’s why:
• In good times, profits grow faster than sales.
Easy2Siksha.com
• In bad times, profits fall faster than sales.
It’s like a magnifying glass — it can focus sunlight to start a fire (profit surge) or burn a hole
(loss surge).
Real-World Illustration
Think of an airline:
• Huge fixed costs: Aircraft leases, crew salaries, airport fees.
• Low variable cost per passenger: A bit of fuel, snacks.
Once the plane is flying (fixed costs paid), selling extra seats is almost pure profit. That’s why
a small increase in passenger numbers can dramatically boost profits — but a small drop can
cause big losses.
Benefits of High Operating Leverage
1. Profit Boost in Growth Phases
o After break-even, each extra sale adds disproportionately to profit.
2. Competitive Pricing Flexibility
o Can lower prices temporarily to fill capacity, knowing fixed costs are already
covered.
3. Encourages Efficient Use of Capacity
o Maximising output spreads fixed costs over more units.
Risks of High Operating Leverage
1. Higher Break-even Point
o Need more sales to cover high fixed costs.
2. Greater Losses in Downturns
o Sales drop → profits drop faster.
3. Forecasting Sensitivity
o Small errors in sales forecasts can cause big profit swings.
How Businesses Use This Lever
• Manufacturers with expensive plants aim to run at full capacity to exploit high
operating leverage.
• Software companies have high fixed development costs but low distribution costs —
extra sales are almost pure profit.
• Service firms with salaried staff (consulting, legal) can also have high operating
leverage.
Operating Leverage:
Easy2Siksha.com
• Measures how a change in sales affects operating profit due to fixed costs in the cost
structure.
• High OL: High fixed costs, low variable costs → greater profit sensitivity.
• Formula: DOL = % change in EBIT / % change in Sales.
• Helps magnify revenue impact: After covering fixed costs, extra sales mostly add to
profit, so profit grows faster than sales.
• Caution: Works both ways — magnifies losses if sales fall.
Closing the Story
Back in our roller coaster control room, you now understand the lever. Pull it in a boom
year, and the ride is thrilling — profits climb steeply. But in a slump, the same lever can send
you plunging.
Operating leverage is that powerful: it’s not just about making more sales, it’s about how
your cost structure turns those sales into profit — or loss — at high speed.
4. Explain the term capital structure and mention the factors affecting capital structure.
Ans: Scene 1 — The Grand Restaurant of Business
Picture a grand, bustling restaurant in the heart of the city. The owner, Mr. Arjun, dreams of
making it the most famous dining spot in the country. But dreams need money — and here’s
the twist: he doesn’t have enough in his own pocket to make it happen.
So, he stands at a crossroads with two main doors in front of him:
1. Door A — The Equity Room Behind this door are investors willing to give him money
in exchange for a share of ownership in the restaurant. They’ll share in the profits,
but they’ll also have a say in how the place is run.
2. Door B — The Debt Room Behind this door are lenders — banks, bondholders —
ready to give him money as a loan. They don’t want ownership, just regular interest
payments and their money back on time.
The mix of how much he takes from Door A and how much from Door B is what we call
Capital Structure.
🍽 What is Capital Structure? (In Human Words)
Capital structure is simply the recipe of how a business finances its operations and growth
— the proportion of debt (borrowed money) and equity (owner’s or shareholders’ funds) it
uses.
• Debt = Loans, bonds, debentures — money you must repay with interest.
• Equity = Money from owners or shareholders — no repayment, but they share
profits and control.
Easy2Siksha.com
A company’s capital structure is like the balance of spices in a dish — too much of one
ingredient can ruin the flavour, too little can make it bland. The goal is to find the optimal
mix that maximises value and minimises cost.
Why Does It Matter?
The capital structure affects:
• Risk — More debt means higher fixed obligations (interest), which can be risky in
bad times.
• Return — Debt is cheaper than equity (due to tax benefits), so it can boost returns in
good times.
• Control — Equity dilutes ownership; debt doesn’t.
A smart capital structure is like a well-balanced recipe — it satisfies the taste (profitability)
without burning the tongue (risk).
Factors Affecting Capital Structure — Told as the Restaurant’s Story
Let’s follow Mr. Arjun as he decides how to fund his dream restaurant. Each factor he
considers is exactly what companies think about in real life.
1. Nature of the Business
If Arjun’s restaurant is a fine-dining place with steady, loyal customers, he can afford more
debt — because his income is predictable. But if it’s an experimental fusion café with
uncertain demand, too much debt could be dangerous. Lesson: Stable businesses can
handle more debt; risky businesses rely more on equity.
2. Size of the Company
A large, well-established restaurant chain can borrow more easily and at lower interest rates
than a small, new café. Lesson: Bigger companies often have better access to debt markets.
3. Stability of Earnings
If Arjun’s restaurant earns steady profits month after month, lenders feel safe. But if
earnings swing wildly, debt becomes risky. Lesson: Stable earnings support higher debt
capacity.
4. Cost of Debt vs. Cost of Equity
Debt is usually cheaper because:
• Interest is tax-deductible.
• Lenders take less risk than shareholders.
Easy2Siksha.com
But too much debt increases financial risk, which can raise the cost of both debt and equity.
Lesson: Choose the cheaper source, but don’t overuse it.
5. Control Considerations
If Arjun doesn’t want to share decision-making, he’ll prefer debt over equity. Equity
investors get voting rights; lenders don’t. Lesson: Desire to retain control pushes firms
toward debt.
6. Flexibility
Arjun might want the flexibility to raise more funds in the future. If he uses too much debt
now, he may have no borrowing capacity later. Lesson: Keep some room for future needs.
7. Market Conditions
If interest rates are low, debt becomes attractive. If the stock market is booming, issuing
shares might be better. Lesson: Time your funding choice to market conditions.
8. Tax Considerations
Debt’s interest payments reduce taxable income — a big plus in high-tax environments.
Lesson: Higher tax rates make debt more attractive.
9. Regulatory Environment
Some industries have rules limiting how much debt they can take. Lesson: Legal limits can
shape capital structure.
10. Business Growth Stage
A start-up restaurant may rely more on equity (less pressure to repay), while a mature chain
can use more debt to expand. Lesson: Growth stage influences the mix.
The Balancing Act — Optimal Capital Structure
The optimal capital structure is the point where:
• The cost of capital is lowest.
• The value of the firm is highest.
• Risk is acceptable.
For Arjun, it’s the perfect blend of investor funds and loans that lets him grow without losing
sleep over repayments or control.
A Simple Illustration
Easy2Siksha.com
Imagine:
• Total funds needed = ₹1 crore.
• Option 1: 100% equity → No interest, but profits shared fully.
• Option 2: 50% debt @ 10% interest + 50% equity → Interest cost ₹5 lakh/year, but if
profits are high, equity holders get a bigger return on their smaller investment.
Debt magnifies returns when profits are strong — but magnifies losses when profits fall.
Exam-Ready Recap
Capital Structure: The mix of debt and equity a company uses to finance its operations and
growth.
Factors Affecting It:
1. Nature of business
2. Size of company
3. Stability of earnings
4. Cost of debt vs. equity
5. Control considerations
6. Flexibility
7. Market conditions
8. Tax considerations
9. Regulatory environment
10. Growth stage of business
Key Idea: Find the balance that minimises cost, maximises value, and keeps risk
manageable.
Closing Scene
Mr. Arjun finally chooses a balanced capital structure — enough equity to keep lenders
comfortable, enough debt to enjoy tax benefits and boost returns. His restaurant opens
with a grand launch, the kitchen hums, and the aroma of success fills the air.
And just like that, capital structure stops being a dry finance term and becomes what it truly
is — the art of funding a dream without letting the cost of money eat away the flavour of
success.
Easy2Siksha.com
SECTION-C
5. What factors would you take into consideration in estimating the Working Capital
needs of a concern?
Ans: Imagine you’re the producer of a big-budget film. The cameras are ready, the actors
are in costume, the director is shouting instructions — but you suddenly realise something
terrifying: the catering truck hasn’t arrived, the costumes for tomorrow’s shoot are still at
the tailor, and the lighting crew hasn’t been paid.
Even though you have millions invested in the movie, without day-to-day cash to keep
things moving, the entire production could grind to a halt.
That day-to-day cash in business terms is Working Capital — the money needed to run
operations smoothly between paying your bills and collecting your receivables.
First, What is Working Capital?
In simple words: Working Capital = Current Assets − Current Liabilities
It’s the financial cushion that keeps the business running between paying for things (like raw
materials, wages, utilities) and getting paid by customers.
• Current Assets: Cash, inventory, accounts receivable (money customers owe you).
• Current Liabilities: Accounts payable (money you owe suppliers), short-term loans,
accrued expenses.
If you think of a business as a movie set, working capital is the fuel that keeps the lights on,
the actors fed, and the cameras rolling.
Scene 2 — Why Estimating Working Capital Needs Matters
If you underestimate your working capital needs, you risk production delays — in business,
that means missed orders, unhappy customers, and even insolvency. If you overestimate,
you tie up too much money in idle assets — like overstocking costumes you never use.
So, just like a producer plans the budget for each scene, a business must estimate its
working capital needs carefully.
The Factors — Told Through the Movie Production Story
Here’s how our “film set” analogy helps explain the key factors that determine working
capital needs.
1. Nature of the Business
Easy2Siksha.com
If your “movie” is actually a documentary with a small crew, you don’t need much daily
cash — similar to a service business with low inventory needs. But if it’s a fantasy epic with
elaborate sets and costumes, you’ll need huge upfront spending — like a manufacturing
company that must buy raw materials, hold inventory, and wait months before getting paid.
Lesson:
• Manufacturing → High working capital needs.
• Trading → Moderate needs.
• Services → Lower needs.
2. Scale of Operations
A small indie film needs fewer crew members, props, and locations — less working capital. A
blockbuster with hundreds of extras and multiple locations needs massive daily funding.
Lesson: Bigger businesses require more working capital because they handle more
inventory, more receivables, and more payables.
3. Production Cycle / Operating Cycle
If your film takes two years to shoot, you’ll need to keep paying salaries, rent, and suppliers
for a long time before you see any box office revenue. In business, a long production cycle
means more money tied up in work-in-progress and inventory.
Lesson: Longer cycles → Higher working capital needs.
4. Business Cycle / Economic Conditions
During a “boom” in the film industry, you might shoot more scenes, hire more crew, and
spend more on marketing — requiring more working capital. During a slump, you cut costs
and scale down.
Lesson: Boom → Higher working capital. Recession → Lower working capital.
5. Seasonality of Operations 🌦
If you’re making a Christmas movie, you’ll spend heavily before December, then earn most
of your revenue in a short burst. Similarly, seasonal businesses (like woollen clothing or ice
cream) need more working capital in peak season and less in off-season.
6. Credit Policy to Customers
If you let cinema chains pay you six months after release, you’ll need more working capital
to survive until payment arrives. In business, a liberal credit policy increases receivables and
working capital needs.
Easy2Siksha.com
7. Credit Terms from Suppliers
If your costume supplier lets you pay after 90 days, you can manage with less working
capital. Short credit periods from suppliers mean you need more cash on hand.
8. Inventory Policy
If you insist on keeping three versions of every costume in stock “just in case,” you’ll tie up
more money in inventory. Efficient inventory management reduces working capital needs.
9. Technology and Production Methods
A film using heavy CGI might have high upfront fixed costs but lower daily expenses —
similar to capital-intensive industries with lower variable costs. Labour-intensive shoots (lots
of extras, manual set building) require more frequent cash outflows.
10. Growth and Expansion Plans
If you’re planning to shoot two sequels back-to-back, you’ll need extra working capital to
fund the expansion before the extra revenue comes in.
11. Unexpected Contingencies
A sudden storm damages your outdoor set — you need emergency funds to rebuild. In
business, unforeseen events (strikes, supply chain disruptions) require a working capital
buffer.
Pulling It Together — The Producer’s Checklist
When estimating working capital needs, a smart producer (or business manager) asks:
1. What’s the nature of my “production” (business)?
2. How big is the scale?
3. How long is my operating cycle?
4. Are we in a boom or slump?
5. Is the business seasonal?
6. What’s my credit policy to customers?
7. What credit do I get from suppliers?
8. How much inventory do I hold?
9. What’s my production method?
10. Am I expanding soon?
11. Do I have a contingency buffer?
Closing Scene
Easy2Siksha.com
As the final scene of our movie wraps, the crew is paid, the sets are cleared, and the film is
ready for release. The audience will never know that behind the glamour, a silent hero —
carefully planned working capital — kept the production alive.
In business, just like in filmmaking, the show must go on — and working capital is the quiet
force that makes sure it does.
6. Discuss the various recommendations of Tandon Committee on Working Capital.
Ans: Imagine you are running a shop. You buy goods from wholesalers, keep them in stock,
and then sell them to customers. But here’s the challenge—you don’t always have ready
cash to buy stock. So, you go to a bank and ask for a loan to manage your day-to-day needs,
like buying raw materials, paying wages, and meeting short-term expenses. This kind of
money needed for daily operations is called working capital.
Now, picture the situation in India during the 1970s. Businesses were growing, but there
was no proper system to decide how much working capital banks should provide. Every
firm would go to the bank, ask for big loans, and banks would lend without much scientific
assessment. The result? Many firms were misusing borrowed money, some hoarding funds,
and banks were struggling with liquidity issues.
To fix this mess, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) set up a committee in 1974 under the
chairmanship of Dr. P.L. Tandon. The job of this committee was simple yet very important:
Frame clear guidelines on how banks should lend working capital to businesses.
Prevent misuse of borrowed funds.
Ensure that loans are given based on real needs, not on inflated demands.
The report of this committee is what we call the Tandon Committee Recommendations.
Let’s break them down in a humanized, simple, and memorable way.
1. Changing the Lending Culture: From “Cash Credit” to “Need-Based” Lending
Before the committee, most companies enjoyed cash credit from banks. It worked like a
free-flowing tap: once the bank approved a limit, companies could withdraw money
whenever they wanted, without proper monitoring. Imagine giving your friend an unlimited
access card to your wallet—sooner or later, they might misuse it!
The Tandon Committee said—No more casual lending. Banks should lend only after
properly assessing the actual working capital needs of the company. Loans should be tied to
the firm’s production and sales, not to its exaggerated requests.
Easy2Siksha.com
This shifted the mindset of banks from being “money suppliers” to “financial planners” who
carefully calculated what a business truly required.
2. Introducing the Concept of “Norms” for Inventory and Receivables
Suppose you run a garments shop. Normally, you may keep clothes worth 2 months’ sales in
stock. But what if you decide to stockpile goods worth 8 months, and then go to the bank
for a huge loan? That would be risky and unnecessary.
The Tandon Committee realized businesses were often holding excess inventory and
inflating their working capital requirements. So, it laid down “Norms”—rules about how
much stock or receivables a firm should ideally hold.
For example:
• Raw material: maybe 1 month’s requirement.
• Finished goods: 1 month’s sales.
• Receivables: 1.5 months’ credit sales.
By fixing such limits, the committee ensured that loans were not given for unnecessary
hoarding.
This was like telling students, “Keep only the number of books you need for the semester;
don’t borrow the entire library.”
3. Three Methods of Calculating Maximum Permissible Bank Finance (MPBF)
Here comes the most famous part of the Tandon Committee report. To ensure uniformity, it
gave three methods for banks to calculate how much loan a business could get. Think of
these as three formulas that balanced responsibility between banks and businesses.
Method I (Most Liberal):
• Bank would finance 75% of working capital gap (Current Assets – Current Liabilities
other than bank borrowings).
• The firm would bring in 25%.
Example: If your working capital gap is ₹100, bank gives ₹75, and you contribute ₹25.
Method II (Balanced Approach):
• Bank would finance 75% of current assets, after subtracting core current assets (like
minimum cash and stocks that must be kept).
Easy2Siksha.com
• This ensured that firms brought in more of their own money.
Here, businesses had more responsibility to fund part of their operations.
Method III (Most Stringent):
• Bank would finance only 25% of current assets, and the remaining 75% had to come
from the company’s long-term sources (like share capital or retained earnings).
This forced businesses to rely less on borrowed money and more on their own funds.
The RBI later accepted Method II as the standard approach.
In simple terms, these methods were like three diets prescribed by a doctor:
• Method I = Eat whatever you want, but with some limits.
• Method II = Balanced diet (most practical).
• Method III = Very strict diet with maximum discipline.
4. Encouraging Proper Financial Discipline
The committee wasn’t just about formulas—it wanted to teach businesses discipline. Some
of its recommendations were:
• Companies should reduce dependence on short-term borrowings.
• Firms must finance a reasonable part of their current assets from long-term funds.
• Borrowed money should not be diverted into buying fixed assets or making
speculative investments.
It was like a teacher reminding students, “Don’t spend your pocket money on video games
when it was meant for books!”
5. Better Information System (Credit Monitoring)
Banks were often lending without much follow-up. Once money was given, they had little
idea how it was being used.
The Tandon Committee said—this must change.
• Companies should regularly submit data about production, sales, stock, and
receivables.
• Banks should monitor this data and ensure funds were being used for the intended
purpose.
Easy2Siksha.com
In short, banks became like parents checking report cards to ensure children weren’t
bunking classes!
6. Shift Towards Bills Financing
Earlier, firms used cash credit for everything. The committee encouraged banks to finance
through bills (like trade bills, receivable bills) instead of unlimited cash credit.
This was more structured and time-bound. It promoted a culture of short-term borrowing
for short-term needs.
7. Classification of Industries
The committee also classified industries into categories, depending on their nature and
working capital requirements. For example, a sugar factory and a steel plant cannot have
the same inventory norms. By customizing rules, the recommendations became more
practical.
Impact of Tandon Committee Recommendations
• For the first time, India had a scientific, uniform system of working capital finance.
• Banks became more cautious, businesses became more disciplined.
• Misuse of funds reduced, and transparency increased.
• It laid the foundation of today’s modern banking practices in India.
Conclusion
The story of the Tandon Committee is like a strict but caring teacher entering a noisy
classroom. Before, the students (businesses) were doing whatever they pleased—borrowing
too much, misusing money, and leaving banks in trouble. The teacher (Tandon Committee)
brought order by setting rules, discipline, and transparency.
Its recommendations—like inventory norms, MPBF methods, better monitoring, and need-
based lending—were not just technical guidelines but a cultural shift in Indian banking.
Even today, when we talk about working capital finance, the Tandon Committee’s name
stands tall as a milestone.
Easy2Siksha.com
So, whenever you think of working capital finance in India, remember the Tandon
Committee—it was the reformer that taught both banks and businesses the art of
responsible borrowing and lending.
SECTION-D
7. What do you understand by Capital Budgeting process ? Enumerate briefly the major
steps involved in capital budgeting.
Ans: A Story Beginning: The Shopkeeper’s Big Dream
Imagine you are a small shopkeeper who has been running a general store for years. Every
day, you earn a little profit, pay your bills, and save a bit of money. One day, you dream of
expanding your business. You think, “Should I open another shop in a nearby market? Or
maybe invest in a delivery van to reach more customers? Or perhaps buy a new machine
that can make packaged snacks to sell along with my regular items?”
Each of these ideas sounds wonderful, but you also know one thing clearly: money is
limited. You cannot invest in everything at once. You must choose wisely, because once
money is invested, it will be locked for a long time. The decision you make today will affect
your future profits and even the survival of your business.
And this—right here—is the essence of capital budgeting.
What is Capital Budgeting?
Capital budgeting is simply the process of planning and deciding where to invest money in
long-term projects that will generate benefits in the future. These investments usually
involve a big amount of money, are not easily reversible, and affect the growth of the
business for years.
In other words, capital budgeting is like planting a tree. You choose the best place, buy the
best sapling, nurture it, and wait for years before it gives you fruits. If you choose the wrong
tree or wrong place, you waste years and resources. If you choose wisely, your tree will feed
you for decades.
Why is Capital Budgeting Important?
Before we dive into the steps, let’s quickly understand why it’s so important:
1. Large Investments: These decisions usually involve huge amounts of money.
Easy2Siksha.com
2. Long-term Impact: Once money is invested, you can’t easily change your mind.
3. Risk Factor: A wrong decision can lead to losses or even bankruptcy.
4. Future Growth: Good capital budgeting ensures that the company keeps growing
and competing in the market.
So, capital budgeting is not just a financial exercise—it’s a survival tool for businesses.
The Major Steps in Capital Budgeting
Now, let’s return to the story of the shopkeeper. How would he decide whether to open a
new shop, buy a van, or start making snacks? Let’s walk through the steps, which are the
same in real-world capital budgeting for companies.
Step 1: Idea Generation – Collecting the Options
Every big decision starts with an idea. In our story, the shopkeeper thinks about three
ideas—new shop, delivery van, or snack machine. Similarly, in a company, ideas can come
from employees, managers, research departments, or even suggestions from customers.
The aim of this stage is not to decide but to list out all possible opportunities.
Step 2: Screening the Ideas – Filtering the Realistic Ones
Not every idea is practical. The shopkeeper may dream about opening a shop in another
city, but maybe he doesn’t have enough funds or manpower to manage it.
In business, the screening process ensures that only feasible and realistic projects are
considered further. This avoids wasting time and effort on ideas that are not suitable.
Step 3: Evaluating the Projects – The Heart of Capital Budgeting
This is the most crucial step. The shopkeeper now carefully compares the options. He asks:
• How much money is required?
• How much profit will it bring in the future?
• How long will it take to recover the money invested?
• What are the risks?
In companies, managers use various techniques to evaluate projects, such as:
Easy2Siksha.com
• Payback Period Method – How quickly can we recover our money?
• Net Present Value (NPV) – Is the present value of future profits greater than the
cost?
• Internal Rate of Return (IRR) – What is the rate of return the project promises?
• Profitability Index – How efficient is the project compared to others?
This step is like weighing different fruits before buying—checking their freshness, taste, and
cost.
Step 4: Selecting the Best Project
After evaluating, the shopkeeper might decide, “The delivery van looks like the best option.
It requires moderate investment, helps me reach new customers, and increases my daily
sales.”
Similarly, companies select the project that provides the best balance of profit, risk, and
strategic fit.
Step 5: Financing the Project – Arranging the Money
Once the decision is made, the next challenge is arranging funds. The shopkeeper may use
his savings, borrow from a bank, or take help from a relative.
In a company, funds can come from retained earnings, issuing shares, taking loans, or
bonds. Without proper financing, even the best project remains only a dream.
Step 6: Implementation – Bringing the Plan to Life
Now comes the action part. The shopkeeper actually buys the delivery van, hires a driver,
and starts the service.
For a company, implementation means constructing the factory, buying the machines, hiring
staff, and starting operations. This stage is often challenging because delays, cost overruns,
or mismanagement can spoil the project.
Step 7: Performance Review – Checking the Results
The story doesn’t end after implementation. The shopkeeper must check whether the
delivery van is really increasing his sales as expected. If not, he must analyze why and take
corrective steps.
Easy2Siksha.com
In capital budgeting, companies continuously monitor projects after implementation. They
compare actual results with expected results, identify deviations, and make necessary
improvements.
Capital Budgeting in Real Life: A Quick Example
Think of a mobile phone company planning to launch a new smartphone. It has to decide:
• Should it invest in developing the new phone model?
• Should it build a new factory to meet demand?
• Or should it expand into a different country?
Every such decision follows the exact steps we discussed—idea generation, evaluation,
selection, financing, implementation, and review.
Conclusion: The Art of Choosing Wisely
Capital budgeting is not just about numbers and formulas—it is the art of choosing wisely
for the future. Like our shopkeeper, every business faces crossroads where it must decide
where to invest limited resources. The right decision can take the company to new heights,
while the wrong one can cause financial strain.
So, in simple words:
• Capital budgeting is planning for tomorrow, using the resources of today.
• It is about planting the right seed at the right time in the right place.
• The process ensures that money is not just spent, but invested in projects that bring
long-term growth and stability.
And that is why capital budgeting is often called the backbone of financial management
decisions.
8. Discuss the Walter's and Gordon's model of Dividend Policy.
Ans: Dividend Policy Story – Walter’s Model and Gordon’s Model
Imagine you own a small shop in your town. At the end of every month, you make some
profit. Now you face a very important question:
Should you take out this profit and enjoy it (maybe buy a new phone, go on a trip, or
just keep it safe in the bank)?
Easy2Siksha.com
Or should you reinvest this profit back into your shop to expand it (buy new stock, hire
another helper, or maybe open another branch)?
This everyday dilemma of “consume now or invest for the future” is exactly what companies
face when deciding dividend policy. Dividend policy means deciding how much of the profit
should be given to shareholders as dividends and how much should be reinvested in the
company.
Two very famous financial thinkers—James E. Walter and Myron J. Gordon—tried to
answer this question in their own ways. They gave us Walter’s Model and Gordon’s Model,
which even today form the backbone of dividend policy discussions. Let’s understand both,
but in a human-friendly story way.
1. Walter’s Model – The “Shopkeeper’s Dilemma”
Think again about your shop. Walter says the decision of whether to reinvest profit or pay
dividends depends on one simple comparison:
What is the return you earn if you reinvest in your business (r)?
What is the return investors expect if they put their money somewhere else (k, cost of
capital)?
• If r > k (your shop gives more returns than other options), it’s better to reinvest
profits.
• If r < k (your shop gives less return than outside opportunities), it’s better to pay
dividends, so shareholders can invest elsewhere.
• If r = k, then it doesn’t matter; both paying dividends or reinvesting gives the same
result.
So Walter basically says: The value of a company depends on how wisely it handles this
profit distribution.
Formula
Walter gave a formula to calculate the price of a share (P):
Where:
• P = Price of the share
• D = Dividend per share
• E = Earnings per share
Easy2Siksha.com
• r = Rate of return on investments
• k = Cost of capital (minimum return expected by investors)
Story Example
Let’s say your shop earns ₹100 (E). You can either distribute it all as dividend or reinvest it.
• If you reinvest, you earn 20% (r = 20%).
• The market return expected is only 10% (k = 10%).
Now, according to Walter, since r > k, every rupee you reinvest will increase the value of
your business more than if you gave it away. So, best strategy = reinvest everything, pay no
dividends.
But imagine if your shop is small and cannot grow beyond 8% returns (r = 8%), while the
market gives 10% elsewhere (k = 10%). Then Walter says: “Don’t reinvest, just pay
everything as dividends because shareholders can earn better outside.”
Key Takeaway of Walter’s Model
Walter treats dividend policy as very important. The company’s value changes depending on
whether it pays dividends or retains earnings.
2. Gordon’s Model – The “Bird in Hand” Theory
Now, let’s move to Gordon. He saw the situation a bit differently. He believed shareholders
are like most people—they love certainty.
Have you heard the proverb: “A bird in the hand is worth two in the bush”? That’s the
heart of Gordon’s model.
Shareholders feel that a dividend received today is safer and more valuable than future
capital gains (which may or may not come). Why? Because the future is uncertain—business
risks, market changes, competition, even economic downturns can reduce profits.
So Gordon argued that the more dividends a company pays today, the higher will be the
value of its shares, because investors feel secure and are willing to pay more for certainty.
Formula
Easy2Siksha.com
Gordon gave this formula for the price of a share:
Where:
• P = Price of the share
• E = Earnings per share
• b = Retention ratio (portion of profit reinvested)
• (1-b) = Dividend payout ratio
• r = Return on investment
• k = Cost of capital
Story Example
Imagine you are again the shopkeeper. Suppose you earn ₹100 profit (E). Out of this, you
decide to reinvest 40% (b = 0.4) and give 60% as dividend.
Now, the shareholders know they are definitely getting ₹60 as dividend. This makes them
happy because it’s guaranteed money. The remaining 40% is reinvested, which may give
returns, but that’s uncertain.
According to Gordon, investors will always give more importance to the “sure money”
(dividends) than the “future maybe money” (retained earnings). Hence, dividends increase
the value of shares.
3. Walter vs Gordon – A Friendly Debate
Now, let’s imagine Walter and Gordon sitting together like two old professors having tea
and debating:
• Walter: “Dividends matter because reinvestment returns vs. market returns decide
value. If I can earn higher inside the firm, I should retain profits. Otherwise, pay
dividends.”
• Gordon: “No, no! Investors are not just calculators, they’re human. They love safety.
They will always value a rupee of dividend today more than a rupee of future gains.”
So Walter is more mathematical and comparative (r vs k), while Gordon is more
psychological and practical (certainty vs uncertainty).
Easy2Siksha.com
4. Assumptions in Both Models
Both models are simple and elegant, but they stand on some assumptions (which may not
always be realistic in the real world):
Walter’s Model Assumptions:
1. Firm finances only through retained earnings (no debt or new equity).
2. r and k remain constant forever.
3. Firm has infinite life.
4. Taxes are ignored.
Gordon’s Model Assumptions:
1. Firm is all-equity financed (no debt).
2. r and k remain constant.
3. Retention ratio (b) is constant.
4. Firm has infinite life.
5. Taxes and transaction costs are ignored.
Clearly, these are idealistic assumptions, but that’s how models work—they simplify reality
to explain the core idea.
5. Practical Relevance
• In real life, companies mix both strategies.
• High-growth companies (like startups or tech firms) usually follow Walter’s advice:
retain profits and reinvest because r > k.
• Mature companies (like utility companies or FMCG firms) often follow Gordon’s
advice: give stable dividends because investors love certainty.
For example:
• Infosys (in its early years) reinvested profits heavily (Walter’s logic).
• Coal India or HUL pay regular dividends (Gordon’s logic).
Conclusion
Dividend policy is like deciding whether to eat the fruit today or plant the seed for
tomorrow. Walter’s model tells us to compare the growth potential of reinvestment with
the return expected by investors. If growth prospects are high, retain earnings; if not,
distribute dividends. Gordon’s model, on the other hand, focuses on investor psychology
and says that certainty (dividends today) is more valuable than uncertainty (future gains).
Easy2Siksha.com
Both models teach us that dividend policy is not just a mechanical calculation but also a
matter of trust, expectation, and strategic vision. Together, they make us realize that the
decision of “dividends vs reinvestment” is at the heart of every company’s journey—
whether it becomes a giant or fades away.
“This paper has been carefully prepared for educational purposes. If you notice any
mistakes or have suggestions, feel free to share your feedback.”
